Makeup
25 items
Makeup at Pay4more: 25 units in stock now. Each listing shows the unit’s grade, photos and condition notes. Read those details before buying. You can return any item within 7 days of delivery or pickup. The same policy applies on Pay4more, Bin4more, Bid4more and Fix4more. You pay return shipping, except it is free when the item is defective or we sent the wrong item. Standard shipping in Ontario is $6.99 on orders under $25, and $11.99 from $25 to just under $75. Free shipping applies only to Ontario orders of $75 or more before tax. The rest of Canada, including the territories, is $17.99. Oakville pickup is free. Oversized items are quote-only and are never free.
Last updated
Browse 25 Makeup deals at Pay4more. Compare each listing’s current price, condition and available shipping or pickup options. Any savings shown apply to that item and its stated retail reference; savings vary by item.
Fresh this week
No new arrivals this week
25 items

Magnetic Eyelashes Kit with Applicator & 50 Spoolie Brushes
$10.19
Save $6.80

Gen See Mixed Media Matte Liquid Eyeshadow - Linen Cream
$49.95
Save $33.30

e.l.f. Monochromatic Multi Stick - Travel Size Bronzed Cherr
$4.80
Save $3.20

3 Head Eyebrow Eyelash Shaper Comb Brush Grooming Tool
$15.78
Save $10.52

Missha M Perfect Cover BB Cream SPF 42 PA+++ No.27
$12.52
Save $8.34

Zegaine 12mm Wispy Faux Mink Eyelashes - 16 Pairs
$8.39
Save $5.60

Fox Eye False Eyelashes 8 Pairs - Natural Fluffy Wispy Lashe
$6.57
Save $4.38

L'Oreal True Match Foundation W4 Light Medium | Liquid
$8.32
Save $5.54

LANEIGE Neo Blurring Powder | Oil-Control K-Beauty
$17.00
Save $17.00

Boko 6Pc Red Strawberry Speckles Temporary Tattoos
$7.55
Save $5.04

COVERGIRL Cheekers Blush - Soft, Blendable Powder
$3.49
Save $3.49

Erborian CC Water Doré - Hydrating Tinted Gel
$21.84
Save $14.56

Heated Eyelash Curler USB Rechargeable 3 Temp Settings
$17.50
Save $17.49

Kiss Blowout False Eyelashes 5-Pack - Wispy Reusable
$11.38
Save $7.59

KISS imPRESS Press-On Falsies Eyelash Clusters Natural
$17.39
Save $11.59

Milk Makeup Future Fluid Concealer 4N Fair 0.28fl oz
$25.20
Save $16.80

IONSGAKO 5 Colors Peel Off Lip Stain - Waterproof Matte
$5.02
Save $3.35

Andalou 1000 Roses CC Color Correct SPF 30 Sheer Tan
$15.95
Save $10.64

Black Radiance Perfect Tone Matte Liquid Lipstick Go Nude
$1.57
Save $1.04

Rimmel Stay Glossy Lip Gloss 470 Perfect Peony | Non-Sticky
$6.19
Save $4.13

Clinique Chubby Cream Blush Stick | Plenty O' Papaya
$25.20
Save $16.80

White Face Paint 30g - Water Based Makeup Kit | BADCOLOR
$7.79
Save $5.20

e.l.f. Halo Glow Liquid Filter - Fair/Light Complexion
$11.38
Save $7.58
Makeup models
- e.l.f. Halo Glow Liquid Filter, Complexion Booster For A Glowing, Soft-Focus Look, Infused With Hyaluronic Acid, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, 2 Fair/Light1 available now
- Glamnetic Press On Nails - Pearly Please | Super Short White French Tip Fake Nails, Extra Short Salon Quality French Manicure | 12 Sizes - 30 Nail Kit with Glue2 available now
- Beauty Kind Glaze Dewy Glow Layer Face Foundation Primer & Highlight Creates A Flawless Filter Illuminating Primer All Skin Tones Universal1 available now
- Heated Eyelash Curlers - 2 in 1 Clip- Type Heated lash Curler Best Seller Electric Eyelash Curler 3 Temp Settings for Makeup Tools USB Rechargeable Natural Curling 24H Long Lasting B2-11 available now
- Gen See Mixed Media Matte Liquid Eyeshadow, Linen Cream Eye Makeup1 available now
- Andalou Naturals 1000 Roses CC Color + Correct Sheer Tan SPF 30, 2 fl. Oz., 59.1 ml (Pack of 1)1 available now
- COVERGIRL - Cheekers Blush, Soft, blendable, lightweight formula, easy & natural look, 100% Cruelty-Free1 available now
- L'Oreal Paris True Match Super-Blendable Foundation, Medium Coverage Liquid Foundation Makeup, W4, Light Medium, 1 Fl Oz1 available now
- e.l.f. Monochromatic Multi Stick, Travel-Sized Luxuriously Creamy & Blendable Color For Eyes, Lips & Cheeks, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Bronzed Cherry1 available now
- 3 Head Eyebrow Eyelash Shaper Eyelash Comb Double Head Brush Makeup Grooming Tool cosmetic with 3 Different Spoolie Brushes for Separating Lashes, Eliminating Mascara Clumps, Grooming and Shaping Brow1 available now
- Erborian CC Water with Hyaluronic Acid, Doré - Ultra-Light Aqua Gel Color Corrector with Centella Asiatica & Hyaluronic Acid - Plump, Softer & Hydrated Skin - Korean Skincare Skin Perfector - 0.5 Oz1 available now
- Black Radiance Perfect Tone Matte Liquid Lipstick Lip Crème Go Nude1 available now
- Missha M Perfect Cover BB(Blemish Balm) Cream SPF 42 PA+++ 50ml No.27 Honey Beige1 available now
- KISS imPRESS Press-On Falsies Eyelash Clusters - Natural - 20 Clusters1 available now
- Clinique Chubby Cream Blush Stick Cheek Colour Balm | Blush For Cheeks | Long Lasting + Buildable | Create A Healthy Looking Glow | Perfect For Travel, Plenty O' Papaya1 available now
- Kiss Lashes Kblm02ca Blowout Eyelashes Multi Pack 5 Pairs, 0.03 Pounds1 available now
- Milk Makeup Future Fluid All Over Cream Concealer, 4N (Fair with Neutral Undertones) - 0.28 fl oz - Medium-to-Full Coverage - Up to 12-Hour Wear - Crease-Proof Finish - Vegan, Cruelty Free1 available now
- Black Radiance Perfect Tone Matte Liquid Lipstick Lip Creme Smokin' HotSold out — get notified
- Black Radiance Perfect Tone Matte Liquid Lipstick Lip Crème Bronze SugarSold out — get notified
- L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Panorama Mascara, Volumizing Mascara, Up to 1.4x Bigger-Looking Eyes, Black, 9.9 mLSold out — get notified
- e.l.f. Camo Concealer Deep cinnamonSold out — get notified
- MLEN DIARY Double Eyelid Tape Invisible Eyelid Lifter Strips for Hooded Eyes Droopy Eyelid Lifter Eye Lid Strips with Tools (108P-33 * 5mm)Sold out — get notified
- Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Washable Mascara, Blackest Black, (Packaging May Vary) 0.32 Fl Oz (Pack of 1) , K1714600Sold out — get notified
- e.l.f. No Budge Matte Shadow Stick, Vintage SuedeSold out — get notified
