Pay4more

Craft Supplies

30 items

Craft Supplies at Pay4more: 30 units in stock now. Each listing shows the unit’s grade, photos and condition notes. Read those details before buying. You can return any item within 7 days of delivery or pickup. The same policy applies on Pay4more, Bin4more, Bid4more and Fix4more. You pay return shipping, except it is free when the item is defective or we sent the wrong item. Standard shipping in Ontario is $6.99 on orders under $25, and $11.99 from $25 to just under $75. Free shipping applies only to Ontario orders of $75 or more before tax. The rest of Canada, including the territories, is $17.99. Oakville pickup is free. Oversized items are quote-only and are never free.

Last updated

Browse 30 Craft Supplies deals at Pay4more. Compare each listing’s current price, condition and available shipping or pickup options. Any savings shown apply to that item and its stated retail reference; savings vary by item.

Fresh this week

No new arrivals this week

30 items

Natural Wood Slices 15 PCS 4.3-4.7in Rustic Crafts (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

Natural Wood Slices 15 PCS 4.3-4.7in Rustic Crafts

Retail price reference$24.80

$14.88

Save $9.92

Paper Clip Decorative Tray - Bullseye's Playground (A: New / Open Box)
-67% OFFClearance
A: New / Open Box

Paper Clip Decorative Tray - Bullseye's Playground

Was$1.80
Retail price reference$3.00-67%

$1.00

Save $2.00

10pcs Rhinestone Heart Beads with Tassels for DIY Crafts (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

10pcs Rhinestone Heart Beads with Tassels for DIY Crafts

Retail price reference$35.00

$21.00

Save $14.00

Plastic Embossing Folders for Card Making & Scrapbooking (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

Plastic Embossing Folders for Card Making & Scrapbooking

Retail price reference$9.09

$5.45

Save $3.64

Catephe 4inch Wooden Rings for Craft - 10Pcs Unfinished (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

Catephe 4inch Wooden Rings for Craft - 10Pcs Unfinished

Retail price reference$35.89

$21.53

Save $14.36

120g Ice Color Rainbow Yarn Worsted Weight #4 (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

120g Ice Color Rainbow Yarn Worsted Weight #4

Retail price reference$33.29

$19.97

Save $13.32

Ink & Barrel 4pc Sports Pin Set | Backpack Pins (A: Sealed)
Only 4 left!
A: Sealed

Ink & Barrel 4pc Sports Pin Set | Backpack Pins

Retail price reference$5.00

$3.00

Save $2.00

First Communion Banner Kit - DIY Craft Supplies (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

First Communion Banner Kit - DIY Craft Supplies

Retail price reference$16.79

$10.07

Save $6.72

ILOFRI Leather Vinyl Repair Patch Tape 3x60in (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

ILOFRI Leather Vinyl Repair Patch Tape 3x60in

Retail price reference$20.32

$12.19

Save $8.13

Jongdari Iron on Pearl Letter Patches 26pcs A-Z (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

Jongdari Iron on Pearl Letter Patches 26pcs A-Z

Retail price reference$13.99

$8.39

Save $5.60

100pcs Light Pink Fluffy Turkey Marabou Feathers 4-6" (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

100pcs Light Pink Fluffy Turkey Marabou Feathers 4-6"

Retail price reference$22.30

$13.38

Save $8.92

20 Pc Toothless Vinyl Sticker Pack - Waterproof Decals (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

20 Pc Toothless Vinyl Sticker Pack - Waterproof Decals

Retail price reference$20.99

$12.59

Save $8.40

Woric 5 Color Gingham Ribbon 3/8" X 50 Yd Plaid (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

Woric 5 Color Gingham Ribbon 3/8" X 50 Yd Plaid

Retail price reference$13.99

$8.39

Save $5.60

15 Pack 5x7 White Picture Frame Mats for 4x6 Photos (A: Sealed)
Only 1 left!
A: Sealed

15 Pack 5x7 White Picture Frame Mats for 4x6 Photos

Retail price reference$9.79

$5.87

Save $3.92

Iron on Number 6 Patches 2" White Embroidered Sew On (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

Iron on Number 6 Patches 2" White Embroidered Sew On

Retail price reference$8.99

$5.39

Save $3.60

Crafare 6 Inch Craft Foam Balls 2 Pack White Polystyrene (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

Crafare 6 Inch Craft Foam Balls 2 Pack White Polystyrene

Retail price reference$45.49

$27.29

Save $18.20

Canvalite 1500PCS Flat Back Rhinestones Nail Art Gems Kit (A: New / Open Box)
Only 1 left!
A: New / Open Box

Canvalite 1500PCS Flat Back Rhinestones Nail Art Gems Kit

Retail price reference$12.59

$7.55

Save $5.04

10 Rolls Rainbow Crepe Paper Streamers for Party Decorations (A: Sealed)
Only 1 left!
A: Sealed

10 Rolls Rainbow Crepe Paper Streamers for Party Decorations

Retail price reference$30.74

$18.44

Save $12.30

wooden clips (A: New)
Only 5 left!
A: New

wooden clips

Retail price reference$10.00

$6.00

Save $4.00

328 Wooden Greek Letters 2 Inch Bold Font Unfinished (A: New)
Only 1 left!
A: New

328 Wooden Greek Letters 2 Inch Bold Font Unfinished

Retail price reference$55.29

$33.17

Save $22.12

Cusmation 600Pcs Green Pearl Beads 10mm Vase Filler (A: New)
Only 1 left!
A: New

Cusmation 600Pcs Green Pearl Beads 10mm Vase Filler

Retail price reference$51.18

$30.71

Save $20.47

304 Stainless Steel Sheets 6x12 20 Gauge - 2 Pack (B: Dents and Scratch)
Only 1 left!
B: Dents and Scratch

304 Stainless Steel Sheets 6x12 20 Gauge - 2 Pack

Retail price reference$25.28

$12.64

Save $12.64

Seajan 108 Star Cutouts 3.5" Classroom Bulletin Board (A: New)
Only 1 left!
A: New

Seajan 108 Star Cutouts 3.5" Classroom Bulletin Board

Retail price reference$12.59

$7.55

Save $5.04

Craft Supplies models

Frequently Asked Questions about Craft Supplies

What grades are available for Craft Supplies?
Pay4more sells Grade A (sealed or like new) and Grade B (minor wear) items. Check each listing’s grade and condition disclosures before buying.
Can I return Craft Supplies at Pay4more?
You can return any item within 7 days of delivery or pickup. The same policy applies on Pay4more, Bin4more, Bid4more and Fix4more. You pay return shipping, except it is free when the item is defective or we sent the wrong item.
How much can I save on Craft Supplies?
Savings vary by item. Compare the current price and stated retail reference on each listing; no minimum discount applies to the whole category.
Where does Pay4more get Craft Supplies from?
Inventory comes from manufacturer returns, retailer overstock and liquidation lots. Check each listing for the item’s condition and available fulfilment options.
Can Craft Supplies be shipped?
Standard shipping in Ontario is $6.99 on orders under $25, and $11.99 from $25 to just under $75. Free shipping applies only to Ontario orders of $75 or more before tax. The rest of Canada, including the territories, is $17.99. Oakville pickup is free. Oversized items are quote-only and are never free.